How does the Simple Pump compare to other pumps?

Simple Pumps are CNC-machined for superior reliability, require less effort, fit alongside submersibles, cost significantly less, and can easily upgrade to a motor for solar use.

Simple Pump Team
9/18/2025
3 min read

When comparing hand-operated well pumps, several factors distinguish the Simple Pump from alternatives on the market.

Key Comparison Factors

Maximum Pumping Depth

Pump TypeMaximum Depth
Simple Pump325 feet
Bison Deep Well~200 feet
Traditional Piston Pumps100-150 feet
Pitcher/Suction Pumps25 feet

Simple Pump's 325-foot capability is unmatched in the hand pump market.

Materials and Construction

Simple Pump:

  • 304 stainless steel pump rod and components
  • T6061 billet aluminum pump head (machined)
  • Schedule 80 PVC drop pipe
  • NSF/FDA certified materials
  • Made in USA

Typical Alternatives:

  • Cast iron or steel (may rust)
  • Plastic components
  • Lighter-weight materials
  • Various country origins

Motor Capability

Simple Pump:

  • Optional 24V DC motor
  • Solar compatible
  • Converts easily from hand to motor
  • Same pump, multiple power options

Most Alternatives:

  • Hand-only operation
  • No motor option
  • Separate system needed for powered pumping

Warranty Comparison

PumpWarranty
Simple Pump Hand PartsLifetime
Simple Pump Motor18 months
Most Alternatives1-5 years

Pumping Effort Comparison

Simple Pump Advantage

The Simple Pump lever arm system provides superior mechanical advantage:

  • Smooth, efficient stroke
  • Adjustable handle position
  • Less fatigue during extended pumping
  • Balanced effort on push and pull strokes

Testing Methodology

We've conducted side-by-side comparisons measuring:

  • Force required per gallon
  • Fatigue over time
  • Water volume produced
  • Ease of operation

Pressure Capability

Simple Pump

  • Can pump directly into pressure tank
  • Achieves 100+ PSI
  • Works with existing home plumbing
  • Seamless backup capability

Most Alternatives

  • Ground-level discharge only
  • Cannot pressurize home system
  • Requires carrying water
  • Limited backup utility

Installation Comparison

Simple Pump

  • DIY installation possible
  • Detailed instructions included
  • Phone support available
  • Works alongside submersible pump

Traditional Well Pumps

  • May require professional installation
  • Limited technical support
  • May not fit with existing equipment
  • More complex configurations

Maintenance Requirements

Simple Pump

  • Seal replacement every 3-10+ years
  • Simple maintenance procedures
  • Parts readily available
  • DIY maintenance possible

Traditional Pumps

  • Varies by manufacturer
  • Parts may be difficult to source
  • May require special tools
  • Professional service often needed

Price Comparison

While Simple Pump may have a higher initial cost:

  • Lifetime warranty provides long-term value
  • Motor option eliminates need for separate system
  • Quality materials ensure decades of service
  • Lower total cost of ownership

Who Chooses Simple Pump?

Customers who value:

  • Depth capability - Deep wells require deep-pumping solutions
  • Dual-use - Hand and motor from one system
  • Quality - American manufacturing with lifetime warranty
  • Backup reliability - Seamless integration with existing systems
  • Long-term value - Quality over lowest initial price

Still Deciding?

Contact us to discuss your specific needs:

  • Well specifications
  • Intended use
  • Budget considerations
  • Feature priorities

Technical Support: 877-492-8711 ext. 6

We'll help you determine if Simple Pump is the right choice for your situation.

Tags

cylindermotorsolar-power

Need More Help?

Our technical support team is here to help with any questions about your Simple Pump system.